It almost seems like the Ugly Mug has won this category ever since we started asking readers to vote by county. Heck, it may be true! Since 2004, this microroastery has attracted a following with its increasing focus on small-lot coffees from farms and cooperatives in Guatemala, El Salvador, Colombia and Peru. And it’s all in such a comfortable setting, with tables, couches, barstools, even an open-air seating area out back. You can’t argue with a winner this stubborn!